Discovering Leadership
← All excerpts

Excerpt from the book

Prologues

From The Discovering Leadership series by Colin Ralph

Prologue 1: The Art the Science and the Essence of Leadership

Leadership:

Few words are used more often, debated more passionately, or understood less clearly…

Ask ten people to define leadership and you are likely to receive ten different answers.

Ask which leadership style is best, and the answer is almost always:

It depends.

Before every great achievement there was first an idea that existed only in one person’s imagination.

Every cathedral, every symphony, every scientific breakthrough and every great enterprise began as something invisible and intangible.

Leadership is the ability to make an invisible future visible to others, until they choose to help create it.

The artist sees beauty before it exists

The scientist seeks truth through evidence

The leader must do both

Three quotations have guided my thinking throughout my career.

They are the only quotations you will find in this book:

Poor is the leader when people blindly follow him

Worse when they fear and despise him

A leader is best when people scarcely know he exists

And when all is said and done, they will say,

We did this ourselves.

Lao Tse

Chinese poet and philosopher, 5th century BCE

(Apologies for the masculine gender. This is a direct translation. It does, of course, apply to all genders)

All that you hear is an opinion, not the facts

All that you see is a perception, not the truth

Marcus Aurelius, Stoic Roman Philosopher

I know I am intelligent because I know that I know nothing.

Socrates. Greek Philosopher

This book does not promise a formula.

Leadership refuses to be confined to a formula.

It is an Art to be practised

A Science to be studied and understood.

And, ultimately, an Essence to be lived.

"Leadership is the art of revealing human potential, the science of achieving purposeful results, and the essence of serving something greater than oneself."

Many of the great Renaissance masters began with a canvas prepared in darkness, a dark or even black wash. They did not paint the light first; they painted light emerging from shadow. True leadership follows the same pattern.

We rarely inherit perfect circumstances. We begin among uncertainty, complexity and imperfect information. The leader’s task is not to deny the darkness, but to bring light into it until others can see what was once invisible.

That is the journey upon which I invite you to embark…

Prologue 2: The Dark Side of the Moon – Leadership Liabilities

This book is a sequel and companion to the first, The Art, the Science and the Essence of Leadership. That book was a journey of discovery through galleries, museums, and cathedrals, across cultures and eras, in search of what great leadership looks like when it is captured in stone, paint, and sound. This book turns into the dark corners of the same sources, in search of what leadership looks like when it fails.

Lord Acton's often-quoted warning — power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely — turned out to be the only quotation this book needed. As before, there will be no models, no formulae, no instructions here. Only lessons, discovered along the way.

It might be expected that this darker journey simply mirrors the first: a graduated spectrum, failure at one end building toward excellence at the other, bad shading gradually into good.

But leadership traits are, by nature, behavioural, and behaviour does not hold its shape at the extremes. Every trait changes character as it nears the edge of the spectrum it sits upon. At what point does conviction become stubbornness? At what point does genius become insanity? Perhaps, then, the usual language of strengths and weaknesses is not quite fit for purpose. It may be more accurate to speak instead in terms of Leadership Currency — of Assets and Liabilities.

Take a leader whose great asset is Strategy. Overplayed, it becomes someone who can no longer decide anything at all — demanding more and more data long after a decision was the only thing actually required. Analysis paralysis. The asset has become the liability, without ever changing its name.

Perhaps, then, the spectrum is not a straight line at all, but a loop that travels the full distance and arrives back where it started — a revolution, after all, is one complete rotation, and it ends exactly where it began. Or perhaps it is closer to a Möbius strip: a single twisted surface on which what looked like the outside — the asset — and what looked like the inside — the liability — turn out, followed far enough, to be the same surface all along.

Either way, the mirror we find in these dark corners — and they are well populated — is not the simple reversal we might expect. It is twisted and distorted, closer to a carnival's hall of mirrors than to any flat reflection. Perhaps, in the end, the loop is best understood as an infinity loop, doubling endlessly back on itself.

Enjoy the journey, bon voyage…

Prologue 3: Judgement – The Decision Dial

Where Is the Point?

A surgeon does not wait for every test result before closing the incision. A pilot does not wait for perfect visibility before landing. A leader, faced with a market shifting beneath their feet, does not wait for certainty before deciding. At some point, each of them acts on what they have, and lets go of what they don’t.

That moment, the moment enough becomes enough, is the subject of this book.

The first book in this trilogy, The Art the Science and the Essence of Leadership, asked what leadership is, and found it in cathedrals and symphonies, in the discipline of the sculptor and the vision of the architect. It discovered qualities: courage, integrity, empathy, self-awareness.

The second, The Dark Side of the Moon: Leadership Liabilities, asked what happens when those same qualities curdle. It found leaders who mistook stubbornness for integrity, and paralysis for empathy. It found that failure is rarely the absence of a virtue. More often, it is a virtue taken past the point where it still serves.

Which leaves a question neither book could answer, because it belongs to neither of them: how does a leader know where that point is?

Not in principle. In practice, on a Tuesday afternoon, with half the facts in hand and the other half unlikely ever to arrive.

The Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto noticed, in 1896, that a small share of causes tends to produce a large share of effects. His best-known observation was that roughly twenty per cent of Italy’s population owned eighty per cent of its land, and the ratio turned out to describe far more than land. Leaders have taken from this a comforting piece of arithmetic: find the vital few, ignore the trivial many. It is comforting because it sounds like a formula. It is dangerous for the same reason.

Focus creates clarity. But the same instinct, pushed one increment further, creates blindness: the leader so certain of what matters that they stop seeing what doesn’t fit the pattern. The principle that promises to save a leader time can also be the mechanism of their undoing, depending only on where it is stopped.

Deciding where to stop cannot be done by formula. It is done by a person, in a moment, with incomplete information and a consequence attached. That act, quieter than courage and less visible than vision, is judgement.

The image that organises this book is a dial. Every virtue has one. Turned too little, it fails for want of the quality; turned too far, it fails for excess. This book is not a manual for finding the right setting. There isn’t one, fixed and waiting to be discovered, the way the essence of leadership was. The right setting moves. It depends on what is at stake, on whether the decision can be undone, and on how long the waiting itself is costing. A leader who has learned the correct dose for one crisis has not learned it for the next.

What can be learned is how to ask the question well, in time to matter.

Six dials are examined here, one to a chapter: how much information is enough before deciding; how much counsel to take, and from whom; how much to stake, and who else is exposed; when to step in and when to hold back; how much to learn from what has happened; and how much to leave behind. Each begins with a moment from history, tests itself against three questions, and closes on an image. In places I have turned to my own working life, where the dial was mine to set, and not always well. Throughout, the aim is to watch leaders in the act of deciding: when to gather more, and when to stop gathering and go. When to hold the line, and when to let it move. When restraint is wisdom, and when it is simply fear wearing a better coat.

The loop that closed Book 2 returns here too: the loop with a twist, where one surface becomes its opposite without ever crossing an edge. Too little of a virtue and too much of it can look, from the outside, remarkably alike, both refusing to decide, both failing the moment for opposite reasons. The Möbius strip was never just a shape. It was a warning that the extremes are closer to each other than either believes. It will be there again at the end, seen from a different angle.

Leadership is not simply about doing more. It is about knowing what matters most and knowing when enough is enough.

Knowing, and then, on a Tuesday afternoon, with the facts you have and not the facts you wish you had, deciding anyway.

That is judgement. This is its book.